As I traverse the intricate landscapes of Elden Ring, a perplexing quandary presents itself: should I kill the Dung Eater? This enigmatic figure elicits both intrigue and revulsion, challenging my moral compass within the game. On one hand, eliminating him may seemingly liberate me from his grotesque presence, ushering in a sense of accomplishment and clarity. Alternatively, could his demise inadvertently precipitate unforeseen consequences within the game’s complex narrative tapestry? What hidden lore might I unravel, or what valuable quests could I jeopardize by extinguishing this character’s existence? Furthermore, the weight of my decision lingers heavily, as I ponder whether the Dung Eater’s story arc harbors crucial elements that could enrich my gameplay experience. Is his villainy excusable in the grand scheme of the world? How will this choice reverberate through the myriad interactions and alliances I’ve cultivated? The stakes feel high, and the uncertainty looms large—what should I ultimately decide?