In the intricate tapestry of choices presented in Dark Souls II, the dilemma of whether to eliminate Gilligan presents itself as a captivating quandary. Should I, armed with the knowledge of his potential utility, take the drastic step of ending his existence within the game? What repercussions may I face if I choose to slay this character, renowned for his role in providing vital services, such as the option to purchase items that facilitate my journey through the perilous lands? Conversely, might there be an advantage in maintaining his presence, allowing for his merchant services to persist and thus enhancing my gameplay experience? How does Gilligan’s fate intertwine with the overall narrative arc of Dark Souls II? Are there hidden quests or items tied to his survival that I could be missing? As I weigh these considerations, what insights can other players offer based on their experiences with Gilligan’s role? Is there truly a right path in this labyrinthine world?